If you’re an NFL fan living in Indiana and preparing for your fantasy football draft, the Colts should be on your radar—not just because they’re the home team, but because they present both uncertainty and upside. As training camp approaches and fantasy rankings take shape, now is the time to understand who’s making headlines, what’s driving roster buzz, and why these developments matter for your draft strategy. Here’s what Indiana-based fantasy fans need to know, when to tune in, and how to find value in the chaos.
A Quarterback Battle With Real Consequences
It’s not the first time Colts fans have had to deal with a quarterback competition, but 2025 might be the most unpredictable one yet. On one side, there’s Anthony Richardson. The former first-round pick brings game-breaking rushing upside, but concerns around his surgically repaired shoulder remain. Team officials are optimistic, but there’s still no clear return timeline.
On the other side is Daniel Jones. The former Giants QB signed a one-year deal with Indy, and while his stint in New York didn’t end with fireworks, his skill set fits what coach Shane Steichen wants: mobility, toughness, and just enough vertical passing.
From a fantasy lens, this decision matters. Richardson offers elite upside thanks to his rushing floor, second only to Jalen Hurts among QBs in points per game from rushing.
Jonathan Taylor Still Has RB1 Upside
When healthy, few backs in the NFL are more productive than Jonathan Taylor. That hasn’t changed heading into 2025.
While his last few seasons have been rocky — marked by ankle sprains, thumb injuries, and early-season absences — the Colts’ offensive line remains a bright spot. Only two teams created more yards before contact last season than Indianapolis. That bodes well for Taylor’s bounce-back odds.
Wide Receiver Roles Are Shifting
This Colts receiving corps doesn’t have a clear WR1, and that’s what makes it interesting.
Josh Downs quietly led the team in PPR points per game last year and remains the best separator in the room. Michael Pittman battled through injury and still finished as a weekly starter in deeper formats. Meanwhile, Alec Pierce posted the NFL’s best yards-per-reception rate, and Adonai Mitchell, the 2024 second-round pick, brings real upside if the QB play holds up.
Rookie TE Watch: Tyler Warren
Drafted 14th overall, Tyler Warren has all the tools to become the next breakout tight end. He posted elite after-the-catch numbers at Penn State, excels as a run blocker, and seems poised to win a full-time role early.
While rookie tight ends typically don’t offer consistent production, Warren is entering a system that has quietly featured tight ends in the red zone. His usage in the preseason will be one of the most important trends to watch before Week 1.
In deeper fantasy formats, he’s worth a late-round flyer. If you’re tracking NFL betting news around rookie performances and training camp standouts, Warren could emerge as a popular sleeper pick by September.
Colts Defense: Quietly Rebuilt
While fantasy drafters usually avoid defenses until the final rounds, the Colts’ upgrades on that side of the ball might change that strategy.
They added CB Charvarius Ward and S Cam Bynum in free agency, while also investing in young pass rushers like JT Tuimoloau and CB Justin Walley. This should improve a unit that ranked 24th in points allowed last year.
If Indy can generate more takeaways or limit big plays, it will boost the offense’s time on the field — and open up more fantasy opportunities across the board.
Colts Win Total and What It Signals
This year, Indianapolis enters the season with a projected win total of 7.5. They’ve hit that mark in four of the last five seasons, but questions around quarterback play have kept expectations modest.
Still, this is a team with upside. If the QB situation stabilizes and the defense gels quickly, Indy could be a surprise in the AFC South. Monitoring the market for Indianapolis Colts odds will give fans a clearer picture of how public sentiment shifts throughout the summer.
Why Indiana Fans Shouldn’t Overlook the Colts on Draft Day
The Colts may not be the safest fantasy picks in 2025, but they’re among the most intriguing. With a potential quarterback shakeup, a healthy Jonathan Taylor, and emerging talent, Indianapolis offers both risk and reward. Staying updated on camp news, injuries, and preseason usage gives Indiana drafters an edge. Whether targeting late-round sleepers or monitoring waiver wire trends, smart, timely moves can turn local insight into fantasy success.