KCs and MotM for Week 28 Feb 14th, 15th and 18th 19th

Post by **slarty** » 20 Feb 2006, 05:42

reds363 wrote:I don't think the deflection on Stalteri's cross was significant but I have seen them disallow KCs for similar in the past so I won't be surprised whatever they decide.

The deflection was described as "crucial" by Andy Gray(?*)

*Had sound down low, and a mixture of Chinese and English commentaries, so it may well have been Jock Lee Sun talking about an Arthur Miller play.

Post by **Judio** » 20 Feb 2006, 07:28

Telegraph continue with NOT printing MotMs for Fa Cup

de ZEEUW (WIG) by David Miller

Henry Winter states the MotM in his report was Hamann

Post by **jacksosi** » 20 Feb 2006, 08:51

How do we get them then ?

Post by **palaceboy** » 20 Feb 2006, 08:55

They'll be updated at some point today on the Telegraph website (or the Telegraph Fantasy Football login page).

Post by **Judio** » 20 Feb 2006, 09:01

Who can we write to to get this farce sorted out

Post by **mat mat** » 20 Feb 2006, 09:05

just daft this, isn' it, how hard can it be to print a MOTM for every match reported (championship, league 1, scotland etc) plenty of other papers do it...

Post by **murf** » 20 Feb 2006, 09:09

Judio wrote:Who can we write to to get this farce sorted out

If they do print them on the website fairly promptly and are consistent (i.e. do it the same for each game/round) then we can hardly complain or call it a farce. I would just call it 'silly' (why cant they put it in the paper?).

In fact those who dont know about FISO would be advantaged as they dont need to buy the paper (but we dont care about them do we

)

Post by **Kenners** » 20 Feb 2006, 09:18

It is a complete farce because the whole season will be decided on it, after the cup final we now have to wait until some time on Monday to see if we have won our respective leagues or not (If there are only 4 or less points between the top two)

Its Rubbish!

Post by **mat mat** » 20 Feb 2006, 09:23

That's the case with confirmation of KC's given as well, so there is no change from any other year.

Post by **Judio** » 20 Feb 2006, 09:26

mat mat wrote:That's the case with confirmation of KC's given as well, so there is no change from any other year.

That is rubbish because at least we can judge the KC ourselves
having seen the goal and post the suggested KCs which are right 99 times out of 100

Post by **mat mat** » 20 Feb 2006, 09:29

Judio wrote:
mat mat wrote:That's the case with confirmation of KC's given as well, so there is no change from any other year.
That is rubbish because at least we can judge the KC ourselves
having seen the goal and post the suggested KCs which are right 99 times out of 100

aye, but you still don't Know for sure, take the Stalteri KC from this week, winning your league can hang on that kind of decision.

Post by **Judio** » 20 Feb 2006, 10:07

mat mat wrote: aye, but you still don't Know for sure, take the Stalteri KC from this week, winning your league can hang on that kind of decision.

Talking of which, did Stalteri get the 3 points on TTF ???

Post by **uncsimes** » 20 Feb 2006, 10:21

Points not updated yet. Sometimes a bit slow on a Monday. Should be up by 11ish, but have known it be lunchtime. Depends whether the YTS boy can drag his arse out of bed.

Post by **Judio** » 20 Feb 2006, 11:29

E Mail from GFM

The details of the MOTM for yesterdays FA Cup games will be available on the website as soon as the Telegraph forward them through to us.

Post by **jakehake** » 20 Feb 2006, 11:53

Stalteri 0 points in TFF
Pennant 4 points
Carvalho 2 points
Hasselbaink 2 points (I'm lost on this though his weekly stats say 1 full game, 1 part game 1 goal, he was HT sub yesterday so surely only 1 point with 7 during the week, TFF shows 2 points for yesterday though....)

Drogba 2 points

Post by **Judio** » 20 Feb 2006, 11:54

Carrick ??

Post by **jakehake** » 20 Feb 2006, 11:56

Judio wrote:Carrick ??

2 points

Post by **Judio** » 20 Feb 2006, 12:00

jakehake wrote:
Judio wrote:Carrick ??
2 points

So no second KC for Defoe goal???

Post by **jakehake** » 20 Feb 2006, 12:01

Judio wrote:
jakehake wrote:
Judio wrote:Carrick ??
2 points
So no second KC for Defoe goal???

Seems not

Duff and Crespo both 4 points

Post by **snowy** » 20 Feb 2006, 12:03

Hamman is a bit of an odd choice for motm. No one else seems to have mentioned him. A couple of sunday papers gave it to finnan, and i think i saw one for carra as well. Oh well. I guess mr winter doesn't have any liverpool defenders in his team

Post by **leeloo** » 20 Feb 2006, 12:03

jakehake wrote: Carvalho 2 points
Hasselbaink 2 points (I'm lost on this though his weekly stats say 1 full game, 1 part game 1 goal, he was HT sub yesterday so surely only 1 point with 7 during the week, TFF shows 2 points for yesterday though....)

Carvalho 2 points? How? -5 for a own goal?

JFH came on yesterday at HT. Got a KC and a booking?

Post by **murf** » 20 Feb 2006, 12:05

snowy wrote:Hamman is a bit of an odd choice for motm. No one else seems to have mentioned him. A couple of sunday papers gave it to finnan, and i think i saw one for carra as well. Oh well. I guess mr winter doesn't have any liverpool defenders in his team

Hamann was brilliant and was probably Liverpool's second best player on the day behind Sissoko. The LFC web poll agrees with me and has them as 1-2 with Sissoko a clear 1st. Think they had Kewell 3rd and Carra 4th (Finnan up there too maybe 5th ahead of Crouch and Gerrard). Thats pretty much the order I would put them in - maybe Carra 3rd.

Post by **snowy** » 20 Feb 2006, 12:05

also, how did carvalho get 2 points? Surely he should have only got 1 points.

Full app = 2, minus 1 (for the goal), minus 3 (O.G), plus 3 (KC) = 1.

Post by **snowy** » 20 Feb 2006, 12:06

murf wrote:
snowy wrote:Hamman is a bit of an odd choice for motm. No one else seems to have mentioned him. A couple of sunday papers gave it to finnan, and i think i saw one for carra as well. Oh well. I guess mr winter doesn't have any liverpool defenders in his team
Hamann was brilliant and was probably Liverpool's second best player on the day behind Sissoko. The LFC web poll agrees with me and has them as 1-2 with Sissoko a clear 1st. Think they had Kewell 3rd and Carra 4th (Finnan up there too maybe 5th ahead of Crouch and Gerrard). Thats pretty much the order I would put them in - maybe Carra 3rd.

#

lol, i was just thinking as i posted that it was probably the blinkered views of all us liverpool blockers

Post by **jakehake** » 20 Feb 2006, 12:07

leeloo wrote:
jakehake wrote: Carvalho 2 points
Hasselbaink 2 points (I'm lost on this though his weekly stats say 1 full game, 1 part game 1 goal, he was HT sub yesterday so surely only 1 point with 7 during the week, TFF shows 2 points for yesterday though....)
Carvalho 2 points? How? -5 for a own goal?

JFH came on yesterday at HT. Got a KC and a booking?

-2 for OG in TFF

and that makes sense for JFH the stats page I looked at seems to be week behind, the daily points is accurate though so 1 app + 3 KC -2 Bk = 2

Post by **snowy** » 20 Feb 2006, 12:09

["jakehake"]

-2 for OG in TFF

[/quote]

Do you mean TTF? Because it's -3 for TFF.

Post by **pottster** » 20 Feb 2006, 12:10

snowy wrote:Hamman is a bit of an odd choice for motm. No one else seems to have mentioned him. A couple of sunday papers gave it to finnan, and i think i saw one for carra as well. Oh well. I guess mr winter doesn't have any liverpool defenders in his team

Not too bothered as long as it was not Gerrard

Surly no-one has Hamman so its no great loss for him to get it!

Post by **jakehake** » 20 Feb 2006, 12:12

snowy wrote:["jakehake"]

-2 for OG in TTF

Do you mean TTF? Because it's -3 for TFF.[/quote]

Yes sorry typo

Post by **Mikey Blue** » 20 Feb 2006, 12:16

Can someone please give give me the full list of MOTM for the FA cup as we all know that they are not in the paper

Post by **snowy** » 20 Feb 2006, 12:16

Mikey Blue wrote:Can someone please give give me the full list of MOTM for the FA cup as we all know that they are not in the paper

read the thread! We don't know them yet

Login • Register

KCs and MotM for Week 28 Feb 14th, 15th and 18th 19th