Week 17 KCs and MotM Dec 5th 6th 9th 10th and 11th

[flattie]

Does anyone else think netting 0 points that scoring your own rebounded penalty is just farcical? Liverpool scored a goal from the set piece at the end of the day.

I think -5 for a missed pen is daft precisely for this point!

[pottster]

Does anyone else think netting 0 points that scoring your own rebounded penalty is just farcical? Liverpool scored a goal from the set piece at the end of the day.

I think -5 for a missed pen is daft precisely for this point!

I can see wahy you think its a bit daft but he should get -5 after all he missed the spot kick - he gets another chance and scores so its 5 points - fair in my book but annoying!

[stevejtr]

And the Stevie Gerrard bandwagon loses another wheel...

[murf]

thats what I thought..

Liverpool 3 - Fulham 0

Carragher (Agger)

Couldn't see who took the corner but they should get a KC.

Garcia (Agger)

Other posts indicate it was a Gerrard corner (hope so)

It was a Gerrard KC

4th goal - Gonzalez (direct free kick)

[Tricky Tree]

And the Stevie Gerrard bandwagon loses another wheel...

5 points will do nicely

[Uncle K]

Man U conceedeing will have pissed a few off - especially if Liverpool keep a clean sheet today.

Not being picky but there has been contraversy on this thread recently - we should put our comments, etc on the unofficial thread.

Comments like these do my nut in. What's the big deal. Get a grip!

[Uncle K]

Would be very suprised if rooney gets a KC. May have been touched by an initial defender and was certainly signifantly touched by the second. Still Roon is clearly MOM.

???? Eh? Were you watching the same game as me? Rooney was good. Ronaldo was awesome!

[Yer Old Da]

Is it 2 Agger assists then?

[dilwar]

yes as i said above

[ealing kid]

Does anyone else think netting 0 points that scoring your own rebounded penalty is just farcical? Liverpool scored a goal from the set piece at the end of the day.

I think -5 for a missed pen is daft precisely for this point!

I can see wahy you think its a bit daft but he should get -5 after all he missed the spot kick - he gets another chance and scores so its 5 points - fair in my book but annoying!

I agree with flattie - at the end of the day he HAS scored a goal which has to be better than not scoring one! Surely scoring your rebounded penalty should be worth more points than doing nothing.

[JonPerkins]

having seen the game live i would give Agger two assists - one for the long cross to garcia - and then his header flicking on gerrard's corner which was turned in by carragher.

...and there was me wishing i had enough to choose finnan instead..

[Yer Old Da]

Does anyone else think netting 0 points that scoring your own rebounded penalty is just farcical? Liverpool scored a goal from the set piece at the end of the day.

I think -5 for a missed pen is daft precisely for this point!

I can see wahy you think its a bit daft but he should get -5 after all he missed the spot kick - he gets another chance and scores so its 5 points - fair in my book but annoying!

I agree with flattie - at the end of the day he HAS scored a goal which has to be better than not scoring one!

Take it you've got Gerrard flattie?

Get it right roon ye!

[saboo]

having seen the game live i would give Agger two assists - one for the long cross to garcia - and then his header wazzock on gerrard's corner which was turned in by carragher.

...and there was me wishing i had enough to choose finnan instead..

Why has it censored fl icking?

[murf]

Bolton 4-0.

Davis (Diouf & prob. Speed)
Davis (Campo & corner taker), highlights weren't clear as to who took it.
Diouf (-)
Anelka (Speed)

[browny]

Bolton 4-0

Anelka(speed)

[Yer Old Da]

Bolton 4-0.

Davis (Diouf & prob. Speed)
Davis (Campo & corner taker), highlights weren't clear as to who took it.
Diouf (-)
Anelka (Speed)

It's Davies.

[Judio]

Only 5 KCs given from 11 Goals

No big teams were playing

Should be a lot more today
From Prem Plus

BOL 4 WHM 0
Davies (Speed and Diouf)
Davies (Speed and Campo)
Diouf (-)
Anelka (Speed)

MUN 3 MAN 1
Rooney (Ronaldo)
Saha (Heinze)
Trabelsi (poss Ireland but only saw once)
Ronaldo (-)

[bejobbie]

from telegraph website:

Man of the Match: Cristiano Ronaldo. Terrified City in the early minutes and his great cross made the opening goal for Wayne Rooney. Then settled United’s nerve by scoring the final one himself.

[murf]

from telegraph website:

Man of the Match: Cristiano Ronaldo. Terrified City in the early minutes and his great cross made the opening goal for Wayne Rooney. Then settled United’s nerve by scoring the final one himself.

The Telegraph website usually uses SUNDAY Telegraph MOTM awards which have nothing to do with TFF so please ignore these.

[Madchester]

from telegraph website:

Man of the Match: Cristiano Ronaldo. Terrified City in the early minutes and his great cross made the opening goal for Wayne Rooney. Then settled United’s nerve by scoring the final one himself.

The Telegraph website usually uses SUNDAY Telegraph MOTM awards which have nothing to do with TFF so please ignore these.

how often have the sunday motm's differed from the monday ones?

[PSA]

Most weeks i think.

[svwhat]

Thought Rooney was MoM by a mile and thought he had 2 KC's - Will he get one for pressing to get ball off City defender and getting it to Heinze for the cross when saha scored?

[svwhat]

Thought Rooney was MoM by a mile and thought he had 2 KC's - Will he get one for pressing to get ball off City defender and getting it to Heinze for the cross when saha scored?

[Arabian Knight]

Thought Rooney was MoM by a mile and thought he had 2 KC's - Will he get one for pressing to get ball off City defender and getting it to Heinze for the cross when saha scored?

Are you kidding - Rooney was good, but not MOM, Ronaldo was superb. Thought Vidic and Ferdinand have more call on MOM than Rooney.

No KC for Rooney for 2nd goal, only Heinze

[Raisin]

The cross to Ronaldo took a slight deflection off one defender and then a significant one off another. No KC chance.

Would have thought the first to Heinze is unlikely too, but possible.

Where is Bram this weekend?

[Uncle K]

Thought Rooney was MoM by a mile and thought he had 2 KC's - Will he get one for pressing to get ball off City defender and getting it to Heinze for the cross when saha scored?

Are you kidding - Rooney was good, but not MOM, Ronaldo was superb. Thought Vidic and Ferdinand have more call on MOM than Rooney.

No KC for Rooney for 2nd goal, only Heinze

This Arabian knows fitba'

[Newbie]

The cross to Ronaldo took a slight deflection off one defender and then a significant one off another. No KC chance.

Would have thought the first to Heinze is unlikely too, but possible.

Where is Bram this weekend?

The cross hardly touched Dunne?? Anyway is this not the OFFICIAL thread

[tyaslevesley]

answer to something much further up the thread

[The Saint]

The cross to Ronaldo took a slight deflection off one defender and then a significant one off another. No KC chance.

Would have thought the first to Heinze is unlikely too, but possible.

Where is Bram this weekend?

Bram's predictions are on his site and his view is that it is possible Rooney could get a KC.

http://www.bramernic.co.uk/fsports/

[thelip]

Bramernic's view on the KC's (taken from his site)

http://www.bramernic.co.uk/fsports/

Blackburn 1-3 Newcastle
Martins (Sibierski)
Taylor (N'Zogbia)
Pedersen (-)
Martins (-)

Bolton 4-0 West Ham
Davies (Speed, Diouf)
Davies (Speed, Campo)
Diouf (-)
Anelka (Speed)

Liverpool 4-0 Fulham
Gerrard (-) but 0 points as a missed penalty beforehand
Carragher (Gerrard, Agger)
Garcia (Agger)
Gonzales (-)

Man United 3-1 Man City
Rooney (Ronaldo)
Saha (Heinze)
Trabelsi (-)
Ronaldo (poss Rooney) although 2 defenders touched it, I'm not convinced either significantly altered it's destination

Middlesbrough 1-1 Wigan
Camara (-)
Yakubu (Viduka, Morrison)

Portsmouth 2-0 Everton
Taylor (-)
Kanu (O'Neil)

Tottenham 5-1 Charlton
Berbatov (Lennon)
Tainio (-)
Dawson og (Reid)
Malbranque (Tainio, Berbatov)
Defoe (-)
Berbatov (-)

Watford 0-0 Reading