Week 13 KCs and MotM Nov 11th 12th

Post by **tedbull** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:32

Dukeg's post is correct.

Welcome to the forum tonyp!

Post by **dukeg** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:32

Here are several sources I used for my last post (i think they're official):

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/main.j ... gbla12.xml

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/main.j ... gshe12.xml

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/main.j ... gmid12.xml

Post by **Jameselaprendi** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:32

Saha is named MOTM on the website. Looks a little different from what ive seen before but it names him as MOTM...

Post by **ethelmoomin** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:33

And middlesbrough

Post by **ethelmoomin** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:37

Think Tonyp is looking elsewhere....

Post by **tonyp** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:40

dukeg's post may be correct so far as the website goes, I don't know. I'm just telling you what it says in the first edition of tomorrow's paper. I have the organ in my hand, so to speak. I'm presuming it's the ones in the paper that count, and that they don't change their minds between editions. Could be wrong on either count, you guys will know.

and yes, it's the Telegraph. I didn't say because I thought you would all assume that, this being a TFF forum !

(isn't it?)

Post by **dilwar** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:42

In that case -

Post by **Jameselaprendi** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:42

Dont worry Tonyp, these people are just confused and blame you because you're new. Strange anomoly if you've read your 1st edition right, because it DEFINATELY says Saha on the website. But im more inclined to believe the paper than the site...

Post by **murf** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:43

TFF uses the Daily Telegraph reporters' MOTM and NOT the Sunday Telegraph's.

Maybe that is the source of confusion.

I've no idea what the Telegraph website uses.....

Post by **dilwar** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:43

tonyp wrote:dukeg's post may be correct so far as the website goes, I don't know. I'm just telling you what it says in the first edition of tomorrow's paper. I have the organ in my hand, so to speak. I'm presuming it's the ones in the paper that count, and that they don't change their minds between editions. Could be wrong on either count, you guys will know.

and yes, it's the Telegraph. I didn't say because I thought you would all assume that, this being a TFF forum !

(isn't it?)

Maybe its a side effect from having your organ in ur hand? The do say it makes you blind..

J/k - welcome to the Forum.

Post by **tonyp** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:49

Good grief, what an ungrateful shower!

I'm trying to do you a favour here!!

I know the difference between the Sunday Telegraph and the Daily Telegraph, and I'm getting quite good at reading now - having been a journalist for the last 30 years.

I don't think I'll bother next week!

Post by **ethelmoomin** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:51

Think we will have to wait till it is after mdnight then with the reports posted on the web. All the reports on the website were posted on 12th (Sunday) which may account for the difference?

Post by **Jameselaprendi** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:51

Hey Tony, i dont think there's call to take it so personally. Thanks for posting, i for one am most grateful. Ive totted up my scores based on what you've said and now im off to bed.

Post by **ethelmoomin** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:52

tonyp wrote:Good grief, what an ungrateful shower!

I'm trying to do you a favour here!!

I know the difference between the Sunday Telegraph and the Daily Telegraph, and I'm getting quite good at reading now - having been a journalist for the last 30 years.

I don't think I'll bother next week!

Much appreciated it is too, although it might not seem it. MOTM is a bit of a contentious issue with many of the awards going to slightly odd places, so wouldn't take too much offence with it!

Post by **dilwar** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:53

tonyp wrote:Good grief, what an ungrateful shower!

I'm trying to do you a favour here!!

I know the difference between the Sunday Telegraph and the Daily Telegraph, and I'm getting quite good at reading now - having been a journalist for the last 30 years.

I don't think I'll bother next week!

I think the Sunday Telegraph comment was aimed at the website predictions, as for my comment it was a bit of fun.

Chill out a bit - no-ones really given you a hard time, I am sure you can see where the confusion is coming from.

Post by **murf** » 12 Nov 2006, 23:53

tonyp wrote:Good grief, what an ungrateful shower!

I'm trying to do you a favour here!!

I know the difference between the Sunday Telegraph and the Daily Telegraph, and I'm getting quite good at reading now - having been a journalist for the last 30 years.

I don't think I'll bother next week!

I'm believing you!

I just checked the reporter form the Man U game on the Telegraph website and he isn't on Judio's table of reporters giving MOTMs to date.

My guess is the website shows the sunday paper's reports which are different to the monday's papers.

Post by **tedbull** » 13 Nov 2006, 00:07

I've always checked at this time of day and the website has been right. Would be strange if they threw a curve ball up but I wouldn't put it past them.

I will get one MOM either way (Saha/Ronaldo) so it's not a biggy to me.

Post by **reds363** » 13 Nov 2006, 00:44

tonyp wrote:official MOTMs from tomorrow's paper:

Toure
Sidwell
Barton
Ronaldo
Niemi
Cattermole
Drogba
Kazim-Richards
Reid
McCann

All the above in bold are confirmed on the website now. Can't find the Villa report yet.

Looks like the previous ones mentioned from the website were from the Sunday online reports.

Post by **The Joker** » 13 Nov 2006, 00:50

tonyp definately right. cheers, big help having someone with access to early edition. dont let tonights discussions put you off posting next week

Post by **Bramernic** » 13 Nov 2006, 00:51

Just got in and watched the goals on the video. I can't dispute the earlier opinions, but here they are in one post.

*** Now confirmed on TFFO ***

Arsenal 3-0 Liverpool
Flamini (Hleb, Fabregas)
Toure (van Persie)
Gallas (van Persie)

Reading 3-1 Tottenham
Keane (Ghaly)
Shorey (-)
Sidwell (Little)
Doyle (Lita)

Post by **Frank_66** » 13 Nov 2006, 00:53

Where exactly are they on the website btw? I can't find any match reports with MOTMs.

Post by **Bramernic** » 13 Nov 2006, 00:54

murf wrote:TFF uses the Daily Telegraph reporters' MOTM and NOT the Sunday Telegraph's.

Maybe that is the source of confusion.

I've no idea what the Telegraph website uses.....

..... both, by the looks of things. The links posted earlier are copies of reports from the Sunday Telegraph. They haven't previously quoted MotMs, so perhaps they're trying to confuse us. Looks like it worked!

Post by **tedbull** » 13 Nov 2006, 01:03

Bramernic wrote:
murf wrote:TFF uses the Daily Telegraph reporters' MOTM and NOT the Sunday Telegraph's.

Maybe that is the source of confusion.

I've no idea what the Telegraph website uses.....
..... both, by the looks of things. The links posted earlier are copies of reports from the Sunday Telegraph. They haven't previously quoted MotMs, so perhaps they're trying to confuse us. Looks like it worked!

Bizarre - I'm fairly confident that they've not done this before.

I guess that first and foremost it is a newspaper. The FF bit is secondary.

Post by **Bramernic** » 13 Nov 2006, 01:05

Frank_66 wrote:Where exactly are they on the website btw? I can't find any match reports with MOTMs.

Click on Sport, then Football, then click on the club badges and look for a report dated Monday. If the latest one is Sunday then it's the wrong one.

The Villa report is there as well and it is McCann.

Post by **Razorback** » 13 Nov 2006, 01:06

reds363 wrote:
tonyp wrote:official MOTMs from tomorrow's paper:

Toure
Sidwell
Barton
Ronaldo
Niemi
Cattermole
Drogba
Kazim-Richards
Reid
McCann
All the above in bold are confirmed on the website now. Can't find the Villa report yet.

Looks like the previous ones mentioned from the website were from the Sunday online reports.

McCann MOTM is now confirmed on website...

Post by **tpartington** » 13 Nov 2006, 01:43

What..you mean all those MOTMs I posted were right? That's spooky....

...because I made 'em all up !!!

What are the odds on that happening? Hmmmmm?

If you're very lucky I'll send you another 11 guesses next Sunday.

I now retire to bed, organ still clutched firmly in my hand!

Post by **tpartington** » 13 Nov 2006, 01:44

PS: I seem to have another name. Must have registered twice. Doh!

Post by **Judio** » 13 Nov 2006, 08:26

tonyp wrote:official MOTMs from tomorrow's paper:

Toure
Sidwell
Barton
Ronaldo
Niemi
Cattermole
Drogba
Kazim-Richards
Reid
McCann

Congratulations to tonyp for seeing an early edition of the paper

All ARE Correct

If you look at web links they were for Sunday Telegraph reporters

Post by **tyaslevesley** » 13 Nov 2006, 09:29

tedbull2002 wrote:
Bramernic wrote:
murf wrote:TFF uses the Daily Telegraph reporters' MOTM and NOT the Sunday Telegraph's.

Maybe that is the source of confusion.

I've no idea what the Telegraph website uses.....
..... both, by the looks of things. The links posted earlier are copies of reports from the Sunday Telegraph. They haven't previously quoted MotMs, so perhaps they're trying to confuse us. Looks like it worked!
Bizarre - I'm fairly confident that they've not done this before.

guess that first and foremost it is a newspaper. The FF bit is secondary.

this has happened several time before - the motm on the website are not always to be trusted.

Post by **tyaslevesley** » 13 Nov 2006, 09:30

double post

Login • Register

Week 13 KCs and MotM Nov 11th 12th