Ratings 02/11/10

ISSACA · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:20

Tottenham 3 Inter Milan 1

STAR MAN - GARETH BALE

TOTTENHAM: Cudicini 7, Hutton 7, Gallas 7, Kaboul 6, Assou-Ekotto 8, Lennon 8, Huddlestone 7, Van der Vaart 7, Modric 8, Bale 9, Crouch 7. Subs: Jenas (Van der Vaart 45) 6, Pavlyuchenko (Crouch 76) 6, Palacios (Lennon 84) 5. Not used: Pletikosa, Keane, Bassong, Kranjcar. Booked: Hutton, Jenas.

Bursaspor 0 Man Utd 3

STAR MAN - GABRIEL OBERTAN

MAN UTD: Van der Sar 8, Rafael 7, Smalling 6, Vidic 6, Evra 7, Obertan 8, Scholes 6, Fletcher 8, Carrick 7, Nani 6, Berbatov 6. Subs: Bebe (Fletcher) 7, Park (Nani) 6, Fabio (Evra) 6. Not used: Kuszczak, Brown, Hernandez, O'Shea. REF: W Stark (Ger) 7.

Read more: http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/sp ... z14AN0CzcY

Vid · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:23

Scholes 6

ISSACA · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:25

First few lines below are from the Sun after match on-line report

"PAUL SCHOLES led a second-half romp that kept United three points clear in Champions League Group C. Darren Fletcher, Gabriel Obertan and Bebe were United's Burs snatchers as they nicked three neat goals. But it was veteran Scholes who did most to add gloss to what was initially a second-gear United display."

But the Sun only see fit to give a 6

em9999 · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:26

bale 9

no way if ever a ten is warranted thebn this is that time

the-postman · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:27

em9999 wrote:

bale 9

no way if ever a ten is warranted thebn this is that time

yeah it warranted a 10

bennyc · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:28

em9999 wrote:

bale 9

no way if ever a ten is warranted thebn this is that time

I actually feel robbed that he only got me 8 points for that performance :lol:

Superstar.

em9999 · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:30

i'm actually quite jealous spurs have him :twisted:

beardown · **Joined:** Tue May 26 2009 **Posts:** 106

Best player in the Premiership BAR NONE

chrispyb · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:32

ISSACA wrote:

First few lines below are from the Sun after match on-line report

"PAUL SCHOLES led a second-half romp that kept United three points clear in Champions League Group C. Darren Fletcher, Gabriel Obertan and Bebe were United's Burs snatchers as they nicked three neat goals. But it was veteran Scholes who did most to add gloss to what was initially a second-gear United display."

But the Sun only see fit to give a 6

Typical Sun Shite, Paul Scholes run's the show but gets a lower rating than the other Midfielders. Obviously they still havn't managed to get the reporter to do the ratings. Maybe next season hey :roll:

Bale was quite good though :mrgreen:

em9999 · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:33

the points should be changed 1 extra point for a 7.. 2 extra for a 8... 3 for 9.... and 4 for 10

it would make more sense and would stop a lot of people being so pissed with the sun for giving a dodgy 7

em9999 · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:33

beardown wrote:

Best player in the Premiership BAR NONE

totally agree :oops:

Rob45 · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:41

em9999 wrote:

the points should be changed 1 extra point for a 7.. 2 extra for a 8... 3 for 9.... and 4 for 10

it would make more sense and would stop a lot of people being so pissed with the sun for giving a dodgy 7

That's a good idea, em....but there would still be disagreements.

em9999 · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:44

Rob45 wrote:

em9999 wrote:

the points should be changed 1 extra point for a 7.. 2 extra for a 8... 3 for 9.... and 4 for 10

it would make more sense and would stop a lot of people being so pissed with the sun for giving a dodgy 7

That's a good idea, em....but there would still be disagreements.

i know it was just a idea...all i know is the current scoring system needs changing..when it comes to ratings...

Glenposh · **Joined:** Thu Jul 15 2010 **Posts:** 49

Vdv a 6 typical bloody sun, he was superb 1st half if he had come on and done that 2nd half he would have got an 8, Adam Johnson played 21 mins and scored a few weeks back and got star man, Vdv did more first half than Johnson did that day

em9999 · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:49

van der fart got a 7

TOTTENHAM: Cudicini 7, Hutton 7, Gallas 7, Kaboul 6, Assou-Ekotto 8, Lennon 8, Huddlestone 7, Van der Vaart 7, Modric 8, Bale 9, Crouch 7. Subs: Jenas (Van der Vaart 45) 6, Pavlyuchenko (Crouch 76) 6, Palacios (Lennon 84) 5. Not used: Pletikosa, Keane, Bassong, Kranjcar. Booked: Hutton, Jenas.

bennyc · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:50

ISSACA wrote:

First few lines below are from the Sun after match on-line report

"PAUL SCHOLES led a second-half romp that kept United three points clear in Champions League Group C. Darren Fletcher, Gabriel Obertan and Bebe were United's Burs snatchers as they nicked three neat goals. But it was veteran Scholes who did most to add gloss to what was initially a second-gear United display."

But the Sun only see fit to give a 6

Can anyone get Dave Watkins to confirm whether the guy who wrote the report also awarded the ratings? If he did he deserves a bollocking and needs to amend Scholes' rating. The Sun don't half make things difficult for themselves re. criticism about the running of the game. It's elementary stuff :roll:

Synyster · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:52

Will be enquiring about that 6 rating, from me viewing a 7 would be unkind. and from their report, an 8 would seem fitting alongside a MOTM award. I'm really starting to think they are bending the ratings to what they want, the reporter doesn't seem to agree with the 'rater' or however you can word it.. it's not right.

Jules · **Posted:** 02 Nov 2010, 23:59

I fully expect Scholes to be star man in the paper. If not, I suggest they do what I told them to do at the HQ visit and publish the ratings on the net first thing in the morning to match what is printed. Although we all like to get the ratings ASAP, it'd save us all staying up late and more importantly it would save all sorts of arguments when a newspaper rating discrepancy affects the outcome of which team/league win a prize

bennyc · **Posted:** 03 Nov 2010, 00:04

tcf wrote:

Will be enquiring about that 6 rating, from me viewing a 7 would be unkind. and from their report, an 8 would seem fitting alongside a MOTM award. I'm really starting to think they are bending the ratings to what they want, the reporter doesn't seem to agree with the 'rater' or however you can word it.. it's not right.

Yeah but according to Dave and Tony Warner at the meeting the reporter and the rater should be one and the same

Scholes completed 100 out of 107 passes and played a sublime ball for Bebe's goal. Sky Sports rated him an 8, Goal.com rated him 8 and MOM.

pseudo geek · **Joined:** Thu Sep 16 2010 **Posts:** 543

bennyc wrote:

ISSACA wrote:

First few lines below are from the Sun after match on-line report

"PAUL SCHOLES led a second-half romp that kept United three points clear in Champions League Group C. Darren Fletcher, Gabriel Obertan and Bebe were United's Burs snatchers as they nicked three neat goals. But it was veteran Scholes who did most to add gloss to what was initially a second-gear United display."

But the Sun only see fit to give a 6

Can anyone get Dave Watkins to confirm whether the guy who wrote the report also awarded the ratings? If he did he deserves a bollocking and needs to amend Scholes' rating. The Sun don't half make things difficult for themselves re. criticism about the running of the game. It's elementary stuff :roll:

Dave Watkins is on holiday till the 21st Nov

SanjayChill · **Posted:** 03 Nov 2010, 04:55

pseudo geek wrote:

bennyc wrote:

ISSACA wrote:

First few lines below are from the Sun after match on-line report

"PAUL SCHOLES led a second-half romp that kept United three points clear in Champions League Group C. Darren Fletcher, Gabriel Obertan and Bebe were United's Burs snatchers as they nicked three neat goals. But it was veteran Scholes who did most to add gloss to what was initially a second-gear United display."

But the Sun only see fit to give a 6

Can anyone get Dave Watkins to confirm whether the guy who wrote the report also awarded the ratings? If he did he deserves a bollocking and needs to amend Scholes' rating. The Sun don't half make things difficult for themselves re. criticism about the running of the game. It's elementary stuff :roll:

Dave Watkins is on holiday till the 21st Nov

When the cat's away, the ratings will sway... :roll:

Ashers · **Posted:** 03 Nov 2010, 07:59

Sanjay - You don't always have to hit the quote button to reply to people.

If you do need to quote something, please edit it so only the key message shows up.

SUZYKINS · **Posted:** 03 Nov 2010, 08:15

SanjayChill wrote:

when the cat's away, the ratings will sway... :roll:

Sanjay only sings when hes winning.
(like that Ashers ?)

SanjayChill · **Posted:** 03 Nov 2010, 09:23

Ashers wrote:

Sanjay - You don't always have to hit the quote button to reply to people.

If you do need to quote something, please edit it so only the key message shows up.

Thanks for the tip Ashers.

Ratings 02/11/10

Who is online