Points Discrepancies 2010/11

Jules · **Posted:** 02 Aug 2010, 18:26

Zimmerman wrote:

Jules..... shall we start a new one and archive this one off?

Seems sensible.

CBN · **Posted:** 16 Aug 2010, 06:41

David Silva missing clean sheet points?

Jules · **Posted:** 16 Aug 2010, 09:55

Only two to start the season with:

728 - D Silva (Man City) - Missing the 3 points for his 7 rating and 2 points for a midfield clean sheet against Spurs. Sun have him on 0, he should be on 5 points.
732 - K Richardson (Sunderland) - Not given -1 points for being booked against Birmingham. Sun have him on 0, he should be on -1 points.

aremis1234 · **Joined:** Tue Jul 29 2008 **Posts:** 109

Jules wrote:

Only two to start the season with:

728 - D Silva (Man City) - Missing the 3 points for his 7 rating and 2 points for a midfield clean sheet against Spurs. Sun have him on 0, he should be on 5 points.
732 - K Richardson (Sunderland) - Not given -1 points for being booked against Birmingham. Sun have him on 0, he should be on -1 points.

The 2 discrepancies, above, have now been corrected.

billvega · **Joined:** Fri Aug 08 2008 **Posts:** 84

They seem to have done very well compared to last seasons train wreck

Hernandez · **Joined:** Thu Apr 22 2010 **Posts:** 59

blimey , never knew this was a problem , has this happened for years like ? :shock:

Trafalgar · **Posted:** 20 Aug 2010, 21:53

520 M Albrighton AV (SDT = 3) (Jules = 13)

Jules · **Posted:** 21 Aug 2010, 08:29

Trafalgar wrote:

520 M Albrighton AV (SDT = 3) (Jules = 13)

I wish the Sun would make their minds up. I had him on 3 and then they put him on 13, retrospectively adding his 10 points for the West Ham game that he was Star Man for before he was added to the list. I've now corrected it back to what I had it as in the first place!

marcusuk · **Posted:** 23 Aug 2010, 09:27

I have Mouyokolo of Wolves in one of my dream teams and was delighted to see he has 4 points which is fantastic as he`s yet to kick a ball this season! Apparently he plays for West Ham now too......come on Dreamteam geeks....sort it out !!!

Jules · **Posted:** 23 Aug 2010, 10:25

068 GLK S Harper Newcastle £1.50 (Sun: 3, Jules: 6) - Harper hasn't been given the 3 points form his penalty save against Villa.
437 DEF S Mouyokolo Wolves £1.50 (Sun: 4, Jules: 0) - Mouyokolo hasn't played this season, so the Sun may have his name confused with someone else?
487 DEF J Olsson West Brom £1.50 (Sun: 5, Jules: 4) - The Sun have not awarded -1 for his booking against Sunderland.
540 MID S Reid West Brom £1.00 (Sun: 1, Jules: 0) - The Sun have not awarded -1 for his booking against Sunderland.

marcusuk · **Posted:** 23 Aug 2010, 10:32

Nice one Jules - thanks for the update

Jules · **Posted:** 23 Aug 2010, 13:03

The Sun have been very diligent and have corrected a couple of errors. The Steven Reid one was my mistake, as I'd not marked him as having come off the bench. Only the Jonas Olsson discrepancy is outstanding now, as there is some doubt as to whether he received a yellow card or not. Some websites/reports say yes, others say no. Either way, one will be right and the other will be wrong, so whichever it is I'm sure this will be sorted out pretty quickly.

487 DEF J Olsson West Brom £1.50 (Sun: 5, Jules: 4) - The Sun have not awarded -1 for his booking against Sunderland, though there is doubt as to whether he received the yellow card or not.

Jules · **Posted:** 25 Aug 2010, 14:18

The Olsson discrepancy is still outstanding. I will update that when I know from an offcial source if he got a yellow card or not.

A new error:
489 DEF G Zuiverloon West Brom £1.00 (Sun: 0, Jules: 5) - He started the Carling Cup match against Leyton Orient, kept a clean sheet and rated 6, so he should have picked up 5 points.

Zimmerman · **Posted:** 25 Aug 2010, 20:29

Jules.... I see that Faubert is on zero points... but he played last night.
What am I missing?

Jules · **Posted:** 25 Aug 2010, 20:59

Zimmerman wrote:

Jules.... I see that Faubert is on zero points... but he played last night.
What am I missing?

...The -2 and -3 he got in the previous 2 games? :lol:

http://www.julianandsarah.com/dreamteam/points_breakdown.asp?code=369

Zimmerman · **Posted:** 25 Aug 2010, 21:04

oh yeh.... them :oops:

hw26 · **Joined:** Sun Jul 26 2009 **Posts:** 1518

Zuiverloon :oops:

Should be on 5 points for his clean sheet midweek, not sure if there are any other discrepancies.

Jules · **Posted:** 28 Aug 2010, 11:56

hw26 wrote:

Zuiverloon :oops:

Should be on 5 points for his clean sheet midweek, not sure if there are any other discrepancies.

Yep, got that one noted, about 5 posts up

Errors/Issues still outstanding:

489 DEF G Zuiverloon West Brom £1.00 (Sun: 0, Jules: 5) - He started the Carling Cup match against Leyton Orient, kept a clean sheet and rated 6, so he should have picked up 5 points.

487 DEF J Olsson West Brom £1.50 (Sun: 5, Jules: 4) - The Sun have not awarded -1 for his booking against Sunderland, though there is doubt as to whether he received the yellow card or not.

Does anyone know of an official source where you can find out if a player has received a booking? I mean official as in The FA / Premier League, not the club website or the BBC!

Zimmerman · **Posted:** 28 Aug 2010, 12:00

in his defence, he'd started a new thread, i moved it into here.

Ole Gunnar Getcha · **Joined:** Thu Sep 02 2010 **Posts:** 1

anyone got any idea whats going to happen with all of the champions league qualifying points that have been issued to spurs players etc when the dreamteam website rules says they are not counted yet they have been added?

andy83 · **Joined:** Fri Aug 06 2010 **Posts:** 11

Jules wrote:

068 GLK S Harper Newcastle £1.50 (Sun: 3, Jules: 6) - Harper hasn't been given the 3 points form his penalty save against Villa.
437 DEF S Mouyokolo Wolves £1.50 (Sun: 4, Jules: 0) - Mouyokolo hasn't played this season, so the Sun may have his name confused with someone else?
487 DEF J Olsson West Brom £1.50 (Sun: 5, Jules: 4) - The Sun have not awarded -1 for his booking against Sunderland.
540 MID S Reid West Brom £1.00 (Sun: 1, Jules: 0) - The Sun have not awarded -1 for his booking against Sunderland.

harper didnt save the pen, carew completley skied it, or does the keeper get the points?

Zimmerman · **Posted:** 04 Sep 2010, 07:44

still counts as a penalty save.

Dot · **Joined:** Fri Jan 06 2006 **Posts:** 18372

Arsenal v Bolton

Irrelevant point Petrov newspaper mark 6--- internet mark 5

RELEVANT POINT- LEE NEWSPAPER MARK 7---- INTERNET MARK 4

ianmorrison81 · **Joined:** Sat Jul 31 2010 **Posts:** 37

Ole Gunnar Getcha wrote:

anyone got any idea whats going to happen with all of the champions league qualifying points that have been issued to spurs players etc when the dreamteam website rules says they are not counted yet they have been added?

There is a distinction between the qualifying rounds and the "play-off" rounds now in the Champions League and the Europa League. The play off round (i.e, the 4th qualifying round) does count for the dreamteam as stated in the rules so these points are correct. I initially misread this as well and hadn't realised they would count.

Rick · **Posted:** 13 Sep 2010, 08:39

Konchesky hasn't been given his 5 points for his clean sheet for Liverpool yesterday.

This seems to happen every year for players who have been transferred.

Jules · **Posted:** 13 Sep 2010, 09:48

104 DEF W Gallas Tottenham £5.00 (Sun:0, Jules:-1) :arrow:

Gallas hasn't been given -1 for his booking against West Brom
198 DEF P Konchesky Fulham £2.50 (Sun:2, Jules:7) :arrow:

Konchesky hasn't been given the 5 points for his clean sheet against Birmingham
438 DEF M Mancienne Wolves £1.50 (Sun:-1, Jules:-2) :arrow:

Not given -1 fr his booking against Fulham
854 FOR M Dembele Fulham £2.00 (Sun:0, Jules:13) :arrow:

Not given the 10 points for his two goals, as well as his 3 points for a 7 rating.
990 FOR P Odemwingie West Brom £2.00 (Sun:0, Jules:3) :arrow:

Not given 3 points for his 7 rating against Tottenham
992 FOR V Obinna West Ham £1.50 (Sun:0, Jules:3) :arrow:

Not given 3 points for his 7 rating against Chelsea
995 FOR L Varney Blackpool £1.00 (Sun:0, Jules:3) :arrow:

Not given 3 points for his 7 rating against Newcastle
999 FOR K Doyle Wolves £2.50 (Sun:3, Jules:2) :arrow:

Doyle has the correct points in his player profile, but his points in the player list are 1 point more than what they should be.

As Dot points out, Chung-Yong Lee was rated 4 against Arsenal, yet in the newspaper he has been rated 7. For the moment the scores tally up, but I presume the website points will be uprated to be inline with what the newspaper is reporting. I will update my points when the Sun update theirs!

Jules · **Posted:** 14 Sep 2010, 08:03

All the points are now correct

Chung-Yong Lee has been awarded 3 points for his 7 rating in The Sun, so it is worth double-checking the Internet ratings against those in the newspaper.

Just a minor issue with my website to fix before all the points are 100% correct. As there are two lots of DJ Campbell in the list, I've got to fix his points for his original listing. His new listing is correct. Nothing major but my match stats validation doesn't allow 3 goals to be logged when a team only scored 2.

jeffmcgow · **Joined:** Thu Oct 13 2005 **Posts:** 375

Jules

You and the Sun agree on Lars Jacobsen having zero points, but didn't he play for WHU against Chelsea and pick up -2 for the 3 goals conceded?

Jules · **Posted:** 14 Sep 2010, 21:52

jeffmcgow wrote:

Jules

You and the Sun agree on Lars Jacobsen having zero points, but didn't he play for WHU against Chelsea and pick up -2 for the 3 goals conceded?

Well spotted Jeff, you're right. I've sorted it on my site and will raise it with DT tomorrow.

Dot · **Joined:** Fri Jan 06 2006 **Posts:** 18372

todays pull-out of goals MATCH REPORT page 12, has HIGHLIGHTED JOEY BARTON AS STARMAN with the same mark as Ben Arfa.

He is also pictured with 6 other starmen in team of the day.

on the web Ben Arfa has been given starman.

Points Discrepancies 2010/11

Who is online