nani or valencia

troytown · **Posted:** 10 Jan 2012, 21:11

I have the funds for either but valencia offers the chioce of sending x amount else where.

I cannot decide - please help

mayweather · **Joined:** Sat Sep 17 2011 **Posts:** 60

neither

mcnulty · **Joined:** Fri Dec 31 2010 **Posts:** 415

Nani is a season keeper for me so id stick with him. Downgrade Baines if you need some money.

gooberman · **Posted:** 10 Jan 2012, 22:38

Valencia is an assist machine and now seems to be back playing right wing. And he is considerably cheaper than nani. I don't see nani massively out scoring valencia. So its valencia for me.

givememcshane · **Joined:** Sun Oct 17 2010 **Posts:** 25

nani simply because once young is back valencia will be a bit rotation issue, but that might not be for a few weeks at least. nani is much less likely to be rotated.

not sure when young is back. few weeks i think

Super Hans · **Joined:** Fri Jul 10 2009 **Posts:** 2597

Why do you think that?

Last year when Valencia came back it was Nani that got relegated to the bench.

Carlb5253 · **Joined:** Mon Feb 14 2011 **Posts:** 561

I think its a tough one.

They are different players FPL wise.

Valencia will seldom score 15+ and i would never captain him. Although he can string 3 or 4 weeks of 6 points + together

Nani on the other hand can go 3 - 4 weeks doing nothing then get 15+ points.

Its a tough one.

Ive gone for Nani, simply because i think he is due a haul.

skittlez · **Joined:** Thu Sep 25 2008 **Posts:** 161

Super Hans wrote:

Why do you think that?

Last year when Valencia came back it was Nani that got relegated to the bench.

I'm with Super Hans on this. Valencia strikes me as one of Fergies favourites.

mcnulty · **Joined:** Fri Dec 31 2010 **Posts:** 415

skittlez wrote:

Super Hans wrote:

Why do you think that?

Last year when Valencia came back it was Nani that got relegated to the bench.

I'm with Super Hans on this. Valencia strikes me as one of Fergies favourites.

I think Valencia is a cracking player. I think they should both be in ahead of Young. Il still never know why Utd bought him instead of a CM.

mcnulty · **Joined:** Fri Dec 31 2010 **Posts:** 415

Anybody know if Nanis injury was serious?

lovoll · **Joined:** Mon Jul 26 2010 **Posts:** 30

mcnulty wrote:

Anybody know if Nanis injury was serious?

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-2090790/Nani-set-miss-Manchester-United-FA-Cup-tie-Liverpool.html?ITO=1490

FCBruno · **Posted:** 26 Jan 2012, 01:35

Nani injury from Daily Mirror

http://www.mirrorfootball.co.uk/news/Ma ... 57463.html

nani or valencia

Who is online