Aston Vlla 0 Liverpool 2

STAR MAN — CRAIG BELLAMY (Liverpool)

ASTON VILLA: Guzan 7, Hutton 5, Dunne 5, Collins 5, Warnock 5, Albrighton 5, Delph 6 (Weimann 1), Petrov 6, N'Zogbia 5, Heskey 5 (Bannan 3), Delfouneso 6. Subs not used: Marshall, Clark, Cuellar, Johnson, Burke. Booked: N'Zogbia.

LIVERPOOL: Reina 6, Johnson 7, Skrtel 7, Agger 6, Jose Enrique 7, Bellamy 9 (Kuyt 1), Adam 5, Shelvey 6 (Carragher 1), Henderson 7, Downing 7, Suarez 8 (Carroll 2). Subs not used: Doni, Maxi, Coates, Kelly. Booked: Adam, Bellamy.

Man City 1 Arsenal 0

STAR MAN — VINCENT KOMPANY (Man City)

MAN CITY: Hart 8, Richards 7, Kompany 8, K Toure 7, Zabaleta 7, Barry 7, Y Toure 6 (De Jong 5), Silva 7, Aguero 7, Nasri 7 (Dzeko 5), Balotelli 7 (Milner 5). Subs not used: Pantilimon, Lescott, Johnson, Savic. Booked: Barry, Aguero.

ARSENAL: Szczesny 7, Djourou 6 (Miquel 6), Koscielny 7, Arteta 6, Mertesacker 6 (Chamakh 5), Vermaelen 7, Song 7, Ramsey 6, Walcott 5 (Arshavin 4), Van Persie 6, Gervinho 8. Subs not used: Almunia, Rosicky, Frimpong, Benayoun. Booked: Song, Koscielny, Arteta.

STAR MAN — JAMES MORRISON (West Brom)


BLACKBURN: Robinson 6, Lowe 6, Samba 6, Dann 6, Pedersen 5, Formica 5, Dunn 5 (Hanley 5), Nzonzi 6, Vukcevic 5 (Roberts 5), Rochina 5 (Goodwillie 5), Yakubu 5. Subs not used: Bunn, Petrovic, Blackman, Henley. Booked: Pedersen.


WEST BROM: Foster 6, Reid 7, McAuley 6, Olsson 7, Shorey 6, Morrison 8 (Thomas 5), Mulumbu 7, Scharner 6 (Dorrans 6), Brunt 6, Odemwingie 7 (Dawson 5), Long 6. Subs not used: Fulop, Jones, Tamas, Cox. Booked: Scharner.

STAR MAN — MOUSSA DEMBELE (Fulham)


FULHAM: Stockdale 6, Baird 6, Senderos 6, Hangeland 6, J Riise 6, Ruiz 7, Murphy 6, Etuhu 6, Dempsey 7, Johnson 6, Dembele 8. Subs not used: Etheridge, Kelly, Orlando Sa, Gecov, Duff, Hughes, Frei. Booked: Murphy.


BOLTON: Jaaskelainen 6, Boyata 4 (Steinsson 5), Cahill 6, Knight 5, Alonso 5, M Davies 5, Muamba 6, Reo-Coker 7, Pratley 6 (Eagles 5), K Davies 5 (Ngog 5), Klasnic 5. Subs not used: Bogdan, Robinson, Tuncay, Petrov. Booked: Reo-Coker, Muamba, Steinsson.

STAR MAN — DANIEL STURRIDGE (Chelsea)

WIGAN: Al Habsi 6, Caldwell 6, Alcaraz 7, Figueroa 6, Stam 6, Jones 5 (Rodallega 4), Diame 7, McCarthy 6, Moses 7, Gomez 6, Sammon 4 (Di Santo 3). Subs not used: Pollitt, Gohouri, Crusat, Watson, McArthur.


CHELSEA: Cech 6, Bosingwa 5, Ivanovic 6, Terry 7, Cole 6, Romeu 3 (Kalou 3), Lampard 6, Meireles 5, Sturridge 8 (Malouda 2), Drogba 6, Mata 5 (Mikel 2). Subs not used: Turnbull, Torres, Ferreira, McEachran.

STAR MAN — LEON OSMAN (Everton)


EVERTON: Howard 6, Hibbert 7, Heitinga 5, Jagielka 5, Baines 7, Gueye 6 (Drenthe 7), Neville 6, Fellaini 5, Osman 8, Cahill 5 (Stracqualursi 7), Saha 6 (McAleny 5). Subs not used: Mucha, Rodwell, Bilyaletdinov, Distin. Booked: Neville.


NORWICH: Ruddy 7, Naughton 7, Martin 6, Whitbread 5, Tierney 6, Crofts 5, Fox 7, Hoolahan 7 (Johnson 5), Surman 5, Holt 7, Morison 6 (Wilbraham 5). Subs not used: Rudd, Jackson, Pilkington, Bennett, Barnett. Booked: Naughton.

STAR MAN — WAYNE ROONEY (Man Utd)


QPR: Cerny 7, Young 6, Gabbidon 5, Connolly 6, Traore 5, Mackie 5, Barton 5, Faurlin 6, Wright-Phillips 5 (Taarabt 6), Bothroyd 5 (Hill 5), Helguson 6 (Campbell 5). Subs not used: Kenny, Orr, Derry, Smith. Booked: Gabbidon.


MAN UTD: De Gea 6, Smalling 7, Evans 7, Ferdinand 6, Evra 6, Valencia 7, Jones 7, Carrick 7, Nani 7 (Young 5), Rooney 9 (Giggs 6), Welbeck 6 (Hernandez 6). Subs not used: Lindegaard, Berbatov, Park, Fryers. Booked: Ferdinand, Jones.

STAR MAN — LEON BRITTAN (Swansea)


NEWCASTLE: Krul 6, Simpson 7, Perch 7, Coloccini 7, Santon 7, Obertan 6 (Sammy Ameobi 5), Cabaye 8, Tiote 8 (Vuckic 5), Gutierrez 7, Best 6 (Shola Ameobi 5), Ba 8. Subs not used: Harper, Williamson, Ben Arfa, Abeid. Booked: Cabaye.


SWANSEA: Vorm 7, Richards 7, Williams 8, Caulker 8, Taylor 8, Routledge 7, Gower 7 (Agustien 6), Britton 9, Sinclair 7 (Dyer 5), Allen 7, Graham 7. Subs not used: Tremmel, Dobbie, Monk, Lita, Moore. Booked: Richards.

STAR MAN — PETER CROUCH (Stoke)




WOLVES: Hennessey 7, Zubar 6, Johnson 6, Berra 7, Ward 5, Jarvis 7, Milijas 5 (Guedioura 3), Henry 6, Hunt 6 (Hammill 3), Fletcher 6, Doyle 6 (Ebanks-Blake 3). Subs not used: De Vries, Elokobi, Stearman, Forde. Booked: Milijas, Berra.



STOKE: Sorensen 7, Woodgate 2 (Pennant 7), Huth 7, Shawcross 6, Wilson 5, Shotton 6, Whitehead 7, Whelan 6 (Palacios 2), Etherington 7 (Fuller 1), Crouch 8, Walters 7. Subs not used: Begovic, Jerome, Jones, Upson. Booked: Woodgate, Shawcross, Whitehead

Wigan 1 Chelsea 1

STAR MAN — DANIEL STURRIDGE (Chelsea)

WIGAN: Al Habsi 6, Caldwell 6, Alcaraz 7, Figueroa 6, Stam 6, Jones 5 (Rodallega 4), Diame 7, McCarthy 6, Moses 7, Gomez 6, Sammon 4 (Di Santo 3). Subs not used: Pollitt, Gohouri, Crusat, Watson, McArthur.

CHELSEA: Cech 6, Bosingwa 5, Ivanovic 6, Terry 7, Cole 6, Romeu 3 (Kalou 3), Lampard 6, Meireles 5, Sturridge 8 (Malouda 2), Drogba 6, Mata 5 (Mikel 2). Subs not used: Turnbull, Torres, Ferreira, McEachran.

Rooney Star Man a nice surprise but then again I don't suppose there are many, if any, in the top 100 without him.

I think that those ratings might just get me a WDT Top 100 spot (or five)

Father and Son Power(1000) in 4th place doesnt have him neither does Ralphs FTM7.(966)

Cyborg Slayers(965) is missing shrek and Hilarious Squad x1(955) aint laughing without him .

Roy Of the Rovers x1(962) is not another name for Wayne so he wont be best pleased

John Marchants JR 013(957) will be marching out of the top 100 without Rooney as will Edmos JO 057 (948) sorry jo edmondsons


Lord Snowdon FC (969) doesnt have him, nor Wishu5 (957) nor Atkins FC (952)

Top Shotter fc(949) also lacks a Rooney, as does Andy Edwards Boa Constrictor (941) down in 97th place


There are others in the top 100 lacking Rooney but i aint checked all the teams and wont either.

WHAT!

I did not see the whole match but I saw the 1st half and he was absolute shite, kept giving the ball away, making terrible decisions.

He must have been awesome in the second half????????

Fulham journalist thinks Dembele outshines Dempsey again, I hoped Dempsey would get it over Ruiz from the highlights.

Any Spurs ratings?

Agreed after watching the highlights I thought Dempsey would get MoM just ahead of Ruiz aswell.

Still no Spuds ratings on the Sun website yet

STAR MAN - LUKA MODRIC (Spurs)


TOTTENHAM: Friedel 7, Walker 6, Gallas 7, King 8, Assou-Ekotto 7, Lennon 5 (Pavlyuchenko 7), Parker 6, Sandro 5 (Livermore 5), Modric 8, Adebayor 7, Van der Vaart 7 (Rose 3). Subs not used: Cudicini, Bassong, Kranjcar, Pienaar. Booked: Assou-Ekotto.


SUNDERLAND: Westwood 7, O'Shea 6, Brown 6, Bramble 6, Bardsley 5 (McClean 5), Larsson 8, Colback 7 (Gardner 5), Vaughan 7, Richardson 7, Wickham 5 (Bendtner 5), Sessegnon 6. Subs not used: Carson, Cattermole, Ji, Elmohamady. Booked: Richardson, Vaughan

I am a spurs fan and was at the game , and i have to say these ratings are shocking !!!

I have Abebayor in 1 of my teams and he was lazy and very poor , Modric was very average and missed a open goal from 6 yrds, Watch MOTD tonight .

Sandro's rating is honestly one of the worst i have ever seen hence i am posting on this, King or Sandro should of got Starman , I doubt this reporter watched the game to give Bendtner anything higher then a 4 is very poor.

I was at the Spurs game too the ratings are rubbish.

Thought Dempsey should have got it. He scored and then gift wrapped a goal. Guess that isn't enough.

Again clear to see sun has it's favourites.I'm not worried so much about Starmen but 7 plus ratings.This season based on players I had or have the Sun have no love for...
Riise
Enrique
Sessegnon

Any more ?

Is there a thread for this
Ie Sun favourites who will always get biased scores ?

I know they dont effect the game points, but there seems to be a real divide in how reporters mark the efforts of subs in games.

This week the games involving AV-LIV, WOL-STO, WIG-CHE had subs rating from 1 to 3. Yet other games such as EVE-NOR, QPR-MANU opt for lets give them a 5 rating or more.

You cant tell me that Ashley Young coming on 88th minute for a 5, contributed any more than say those getting 1 in the AV-LIV game: Weimann(80th min), Carragher(83), Kuyt(88)

I personally think the lower ratings are more accurate, but either way just wish the reporters would all be using the same scoring criteria.

For what its worth, I was at the Norwich game on saturday and I think their sub Drenthe should have been star man, really saved the game for them

Swansea ratings are another joke for parking the bus and getting out of jail.

Think all of their players got a merit mark as they did when they played Liverpool.


Brings you back to midweek and Fulhams 2-2 draw with i beleive from memory one or no Fulham players getting a merit mark and MOTM going to the Odense sub for his his 15 min cameo.


They certainly dont like Dempsey this year.

Terry got given a 6 in the match report, but has been given the points for a 7. I wonder if they will change it or let him keep the points.

the marking up of Spurs defenders has become farcical. Who is responsible and who knew about it? Woeful.

If Pat Spurs filth Sheehan covers the game he marks all the Spurs players up like Swansea when they park the bus.

He has been covering the boxing lately so Spurs marks aint been as biased as normal although judging by reports of how dire they were this weekend maybe he has an apprentice.

So did Ruiz