Elite League - Champions League - JOHNBOY

Zimmerman · **Posted:** 07 Nov 2011, 10:22

For those of you not following the threads;

It seems Johnboy has had some of his teams disqualified (presumably for breaching the 1 free team per manager rule).
Perhaps John can clear this up for us?

Consequently - how do we view this? Does he deserve to stay in our comps or not?
Bearing in mind, that (presumably) he wont be able to make transfers at the next window.

So three options:
a) we keep taking his scores for as long as they are available and he stays in our comp (what happens if he disappears further down the line)?
b) all the games involving him thus far are null and void (and he's evicted)
c) all the results stand, but he is evicted.

Any one else got an alternative suggestion?

NOTE: he's also 21st in the overall Elite League (if this has any bearing on your thoughts).

NOTE2:

Johnboy 18 +80
Nedved 6 +44
Gouvin 6 -15
Superior 6 -17
Ashers 6 -92
---------------
Nedved 6 +49
Superior 6 +7
Gouvin 6 +6
Ashers 6 -62

PLEASE LET ME KNOW YOUR THOUGHTS, AND DO IT VIA PM IF YOU FEEL UNCOMFORTABLE PUBLICLY AIRING YOUR OPINION (ONE WAY OR THE OTHER).

Cheers

sleuth · **Joined:** Sun Apr 03 2011 **Posts:** 2549

Chuck him out..

Was late making hios payment the other year too.

Mad Dog Post subject: Re: SDT ELITE MINI LEAGUE 2010-11 ENTRY NOW CLOSED!!! Posted: 13 Aug 2010, 07:44

Comments: 940
Views: 15182

Yeah half 11 is fine with me - that'll sort out the Hart/Given problem no-one should get an advantage - take the shot at 1130 and then again at 1230

I'll have to omit johnboy72 and mullet boy still no payment and I'm now about to set off

llama · **Posted:** 07 Nov 2011, 17:01

I think it would be harsh to kick him out.

He hasnt broken any of the Elite League rules has he?

chrispyb · **Posted:** 07 Nov 2011, 17:08

I dont mind keeping him in as long as we can reasonably track his scores still?

ken thorn · **Posted:** 07 Nov 2011, 19:02

throw him out and ban him for life, hes well dodgy, name and shame him haha. hes a mate of mine, he knows hes been caught out but is hoping to get his teams back. the team in the elite league is actually his propper free team. its the first time hes done elite league so i dont know how he was late paying last season.

Arch Stanton · **Joined:** Mon Aug 07 2006 **Posts:** 452

Keep him in!

He is very funny, one of life's natural (unintentional) comedians.

I don't know him personally like Ken but from what I have read on these forums I am fairly sure he is not dodgy, just daft.

JOHNBOY72 · **Joined:** Mon Jul 28 2008 **Posts:** 112

yes u all need me 8-)

jeffmcgow · **Joined:** Thu Oct 13 2005 **Posts:** 375

If it's a multi-free entrant then one possibility is for johnboy to resign from the minileague (with a £10 refund). I don't think we can expel anyone unless of course it's covered in MadDog's T&Cs.

ken thorn · **Posted:** 07 Nov 2011, 19:19

ive sent him to the naughty corner, he said hes very sorry. He has paid his money and he cant do any transfers, i vote let him stay, we need a village idiot :lol:

Footy66 · **Posted:** 07 Nov 2011, 20:51

Can stay in

Vid · **Posted:** 07 Nov 2011, 21:11

Whilst his team is producing a score then fair enough to leave him in as he has paid his entry. There may be an issue if the team is completely removed from the game further down the line though. As this eventuality hasn't been considered I'd say that should his team be deleted then it simply scores zero from that point gaining his opponent(s) walk overs.

Ashers · **Posted:** 07 Nov 2011, 21:11

I would suggest he replaces this team with the team the Sun allowed him to keep.

chrismar · **Posted:** 07 Nov 2011, 21:26

Vid wrote:

Whilst his team is producing a score then fair enough to leave him in as he has paid his entry. There may be an issue if the team is completely removed from the game further down the line though. As this eventuality hasn't been considered I'd say that should his team be deleted then it simply scores zero from that point gaining his opponent(s) walk overs.

Agreed, and if he can't do transfers then he shouldn't have cheated in the first place so leave him in and let him suffer.

JOHNBOY72 · **Joined:** Mon Jul 28 2008 **Posts:** 112

Ashers wrote:

I would suggest he replaces this team with the team the Sun allowed him to keep.

sun did not leave me with a team, as i cant do trans, do you want me to help you 8-)

im gutted, 1st time i entered this, but i have paid, and cant do trans, so surely i should stay in....

JOHNBOY72 · **Joined:** Mon Jul 28 2008 **Posts:** 112

Arch Stanton wrote:

Keep him in!

He is very funny, one of life's natural (unintentional) comedians.

I don't know him personally like Ken but from what I have read on these forums I am fairly sure he is not dodgy, just daft.

here arch , get in Andy Johnson, as i cant use trans..... 8-)

Stoneybatter · **Posted:** 07 Nov 2011, 23:47

As long as his team can be tracked for pts I don't see why he should be evicted. While I don't condone his entering multiple free teams, this has nothing to do with the elite league. He paid his £10 and entered one team the same as everybody else and hasn't broken any elite league rules. I think it would be unsporting of us to kick him under these circumstances. His beef is with the Sun, not us. If he does get kicked then I thinks it's fair he gets his £10 returned.

Chrisharry12345 · **Posted:** 08 Nov 2011, 10:14

Happy for him to stay

papiss dog · **Posted:** 08 Nov 2011, 10:22

I'd say let him stay in, regardless of the sun this is a fiso competition, he's entered his team and paid his money, I'd say let him carry on someone can manually add his points up -( not me ) and he'll have to declare his transfers on here before each cut off point.

maybe as punishment he'll have to adopt a norwich city avatar - that'll teach him

papiss dog · **Posted:** 08 Nov 2011, 10:24

Stoneybatter wrote:

As long as his team can be tracked for pts I don't see why he should be evicted. While I don't condone his entering multiple free teams, this has nothing to do with the elite league. He paid his £10 and entered one team the same as everybody else and hasn't broken any elite league rules. I think it would be unsporting of us to kick him under these circumstances. His beef is with the Sun, not us. If he does get kicked then I thinks it's fair he gets his £10 returned.

tottally agree, the sun don't have nothing to do with us, plus I pay out quicker too :lol:

JOHNBOY72 · **Joined:** Mon Jul 28 2008 **Posts:** 112

Mad Dog wrote:

Stoneybatter wrote:

As long as his team can be tracked for pts I don't see why he should be evicted. While I don't condone his entering multiple free teams, this has nothing to do with the elite league. He paid his £10 and entered one team the same as everybody else and hasn't broken any elite league rules. I think it would be unsporting of us to kick him under these circumstances. His beef is with the Sun, not us. If he does get kicked then I thinks it's fair he gets his £10 returned.

tottally agree, the sun don't have nothing to do with us, plus I pay out quicker too :lol:

THX

Footy66 · **Posted:** 08 Nov 2011, 14:38

He can stay in aslong as he splits the winnings with me if he wins.

bloggie · **Posted:** 08 Nov 2011, 14:43

Zimmerman · **Posted:** 10 Nov 2011, 16:07

Any more thoughts/comments?

Thinking at the moment is he stays. If you object, SPEAK UP NOW.

Johnboy, send me your team by PM as we may need to manually track it.

PNE4PREM · **Posted:** 10 Nov 2011, 20:08

Happy for him to stay

Elite League - Champions League - JOHNBOY

Who is online