A mile in another mans shoes...

Zimmerman · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 08:55

A quick game… deadline for entry is midnight tonight (TUE 06/09);

If you were top and this was your team, what changes would you have made?

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5
Richard Dunne 3.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

= £50m

Ashers · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 09:05

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5 :arrow:

Huth 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

Mertesacker 3.5
Richard Dunne 3.5
Fabricio Coloccini
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 :arrow:

Arteta 4.5
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

kabuchi7 · **Joined:** Thu Aug 11 2011 **Posts:** 53

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

Metsacker 3.5
Richard Dunne 3.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0 :arrow:

Johnson 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 :arrow:

Arteta 4.5
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

50 mil

blessedbrian · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 09:09

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

Smalling 4.0
Richard Dunne 3.5 :arrow:

Bosingwa 4.0
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 :arrow:

Mata 3.5
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

= £50m

CBN · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 09:10

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

Per Mertesacker 3.5
Richard Dunne 3.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0 :arrow:

Jonathan Woodgate 1.5
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 :arrow:

Theo Walcott 5.0
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

= £50.0

To be fair I also wanted to get rid of Dunne, Hart and Suarez (bad TW2 imho) so I don't rate this winning team overly.

WNP · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 09:10

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

Mertesacker 3.5
Richard Dunne 3.5 :arrow:

Santos 2.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 :arrow:

Dempsey 4.0
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

= £48m

Zimmerman · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 09:13

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

P Jones 3.5
Richard Dunne 3.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0 :arrow:

Enrique 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 :arrow:

Mata 3.5
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0
= £49m

Chuck Taylor · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 09:21

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

Jones 3.5
Richard Dunne 3.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5 :arrow:

Nasri 6.0
Charlie Adam 4.5
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0 :arrow:

RVP 7.5

= £50m

controversial :lol:

juckster · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 09:21

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 - Mertsacker 3.5
Richard Dunne 3.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 - Bale 5.0
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0 - Zamora 3.5
Wayne Rooney 8.0

= £50m

davewhites · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 09:36

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

Hangeland
Richard Dunne 3.5 :arrow:

Mertesacker
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 :arrow:

Dempsey
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

kid kongo · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 09:56

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 Mertesacker 3.5
Richard Dunne 3.5 Santos 2.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 Walcott 5.0
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

= £49m

sleuth · **Joined:** Sun Apr 03 2011 **Posts:** 2549

Joe Hart 4.5 :arrow:

Schwarzer 2.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

Hangeland 4.0
Richard Dunne 3.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 :arrow:

Nasri 6.0
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

= £50m

dreamteamwinner1112 · **Joined:** Sat Aug 06 2011 **Posts:** 84

If you were top and this was your team, what changes would you have made?

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5. --------- smalling
Richard Dunne 3.5 -------- jones
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 --------- Dempsey
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

= £50m

bigsheff · **Joined:** Thu Oct 15 2009 **Posts:** 1691

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

Smalling 3.5 (changed to P Jones by Zimm :wink:

)
Richard Dunne 3.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0 :arrow:

Enrique 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

Giggs11 · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 10:16

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

Woodgate 1.5
Richard Dunne 3.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0 :arrow:

Warnock 2
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5 :arrow:

Van Percy 7.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

= £50m

kumothokjet · **Joined:** Thu Jul 21 2011 **Posts:** 308

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5 > smalling 4
Gary Cahill 3.5
Richard Dunne 3.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0 > santos 2.5
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 > Mata 3.5
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

Teletubs · **Joined:** Fri Aug 26 2011 **Posts:** 203

J. Hart
R. Shawcross
G. Cahill :arrow:

J. Enrique
R. Dunne :arrow:

P. Jones
F. Coloccini :arrow:

P. Mertesacker
A. Young
C. Adam
D. Silva
L. Suarez
E. Dzeko
W. Rooney

Rick · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 11:12

Didn't see this until now unfortunately.

Very strange as the leader still has exactly the same team but showing as Cahill 0 points

. If he had him before the window how is this possible ? Unless he took him out one day, then changed his mind and put him back in another.

Bit surprised at how few transfers the leading teams have done.

juckster · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 11:30

Knowing how the game has developed this year - probably a cock up on The Sun's side.

Zimmerman · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 12:23

Rick wrote:

Didn't see this until now unfortunately.

Rick, only set this up today… so have a go if you like.

Rick · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 12:33

Oh Yeh

.

So that is right then, looks like the leader brought in Cahill :shock:

as his only change.

Don't know what he had originally, but based on this team I would probably have gone:

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

Mertesacker
Richard Dunne 3.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0 :arrow:

Enrique
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 :arrow:

Parker
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

Miles_T · **Joined:** Thu Oct 13 2005 **Posts:** 1775

blessedbrian wrote:

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

Smalling 4.0
Richard Dunne 3.5 :arrow:

Bosingwa 4.0
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 :arrow:

Mata 3.5
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

= £50m

Spooky! before seeing the list these were what I was going to suggest :shock:

blessedbrian · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 13:16

Miles_T wrote:

blessedbrian wrote:

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

Smalling 4.0
Richard Dunne 3.5 :arrow:

Bosingwa 4.0
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 :arrow:

Mata 3.5
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

= £50m

Spooky! before seeing the list these were what I was going to suggest :shock:

I guess that makes me the winner :wink:

come to think of it, what is the actual aim of this sidegame Zimm :lol:

Zimmerman · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 13:48

Like all the discussions on FISO… absolutely nothing

Guess come TW2 we'll see if any of us were good enough to have kept the team at the top (or at least outscore the original owner (who chose not to make any transfers)).

the pom · **Joined:** Thu Oct 13 2005 **Posts:** 1564

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

(J Woodgate 1.5)
Richard Dunne 3.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0 :arrow:

(A Santos 2.5)
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0 :arrow:

(S Aguero 5.5)
Wayne Rooney 8.0

Rick · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 15:42

Zimmerman wrote:

Like all the discussions on FISO… absolutely nothing

Guess come TW2 we'll see if any of us were good enough to have kept the team at the top (or at least outscore the original owner (who chose not to make any transfers)).

Actually it looks like he did one.

Brought in Cahill.

Will be interesting to see how many of our replacement players outscore him seeing as everyone and their dog has decided they would kick him out.

Zimmerman · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 15:54

But he had Cahill prior to the window (as well).

llama · **Posted:** 06 Sep 2011, 15:55

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5.........P Jones 3.5
Richard Dunne 3.5
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5......O'Hara 2.5
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0.........Hernandez 6
Wayne Rooney 8.0

SmallTimeCharlie · **Joined:** Sat Aug 13 2011 **Posts:** 13

Miles_T wrote:

blessedbrian wrote:

Joe Hart 4.5
Ryan Shawcross 3.5
Gary Cahill 3.5 :arrow:

Smalling 4.0
Richard Dunne 3.5 :arrow:

Bosingwa 4.0
Fabricio Coloccini 2.0
Ashley Young 5.5
Charlie Adam 4.5 :arrow:

Mata 3.5
David Silva 5.5
Luis Suarez 5.5
Edin Dzeko 4.0
Wayne Rooney 8.0

= £50m

Spooky! before seeing the list these were what I was going to suggest :shock:

Thirded. Who's taking out Ashley Young?? Or Charlie Adam, main midfield man for Top4 team?

Is it the case that most people will have very similar forward lines now and the winner will have the right combination of cheap defenders?

Zimmerman · **Posted:** 08 Sep 2011, 21:00

Top Outgoing
Cahill 19
Adam 15
Coloccini 9
Dunne 7
Dzeko 3
Shawcross 2
Hart 1
Young 1
Suarez 1
Rooney 1
Silva 0

Top Incoming
Mertesacker 9
P Jones 6
Enrique 4
Smalling 4
Santos 4
Mata 4

Big Sheff had gone over budget bringing in Smalling, so I subbed in Jones instead.

Full list of players used (originals in colour).
Hart 19
Schwarzer 1

Shawcross 18
Dunne 13
Coloccini 11
Mertesacker 9
P Jones 6
Enrique 4
Smalling 4
Santos 4
Woodgate 3
Bosingwa 2
Hangeland 2
Cahill 1
R Johnson 1
Huth 1
Warnock 1

Silva 20
Young 19
Adam 5
Mata 4
Dempsey 3
Arteta 2
Nasri 2
Walcott 2
Bale 1
O'Hara 1
Parker 1

Suarez 19
Rooney 19
Dzeko 17
Van Persie 2
Hernandez 1
Aguero 1
Zamora 1

A mile in another mans shoes...

Who is online